Monday, September 30, 2013

The Modern Puritan

In todays society there are many social inclinations, in response to socially unacceptable acts, that i believe are similar to the punishment that would be given in a Puritan society. An example that comes to mind is the tendency to shun someone who has committed a crime (and released back into the community). This sort of punishment isn't enforced by federal law, but neighborhoods of people tend to ostracize someone if they see them as a threat or wrong doer. In the scarlet letter Hester is sentenced to wear the letter A on her chest as punishment for adultery, therefore removing her from her position as an accepted part of the puritan community and making her unable to lead a normal life in that town. We see this today to a lesser extent. When a sex offender is convicted they are registered and everyone with access to a computer can see what they did and when they did it. Although the convict is not forced to publicly showcase what they did at every moment the neighborhood is usually alerted and in most cases the convict is shunned and perhaps protested to a point where they have to leave their neghborhood. The 'crime' of adultery was considered a very serious offense in a Puritan society, and today an adulterer is, by nature, shunned by people around him/her such as family and friends, as they have indeed sinned. In this way puritan morals have been adapted into society, subconsciously, targeting criminals and unethical people as punishment for their acts, so others will not repeat them, and to better the community as a whole.

3 comments:

  1. Well well well Noah, your last minute draft is actually good. Shows what you could do with more time. Noah, each point made was valid, and these things will continue to happen. However, I think federal law itself makes such things illegal (i.e. discrimination). And of course, one must remember that sex offenders are required to tell people in the neighborhood anyways, and blah blah blah. So yeah, great work, just don't last minute it again.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Very interesting points, and I like the comparison of adultery in modern verses Puritan society. Somewhat tying in with "there goes the neighborhood", a sex-offender or criminal would make the neighborhood less valuable since it is now deemed "unsafe". However, there is a difference between neighborhoods and Puritans. Inhabitants also would move out as well, in fear of a criminal living so close to them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Good comparison on past to modern day. Do you think the consequences and punishments are the major differences between each one? What else is different?

    ReplyDelete